Euclidean Relativity (a.k.a. 'proper time physics' or 'proper time geometry')
Relativity theory traditionally uses the Minkowski hyperbolic framework. Euclidean relativity proposes a circular geometry as alternative that uses proper time
as the fourth spatial dimension. Other common elements in Euclidean relativity are the Euclidean (++++) metric as opposed to the traditional Minkowski (+---) or (-+++) metric, and the
universal velocity c for all objects in 4D space-time.
The Euclidean metric is derived from the Minkowski metric by rewriting
into the equivalent
The roles of time t and proper time have switched so that proper time becomes
the coordinate for the 4th spatial dimension. The universal velocity c appears from the regular time derivative
The switch impacts all relativistic formulas for displacement, velocity, acceleration and so on in a similar way; invariants are based on t while vector components representing the
4th dimension are based on . Many Euclidean
interpretations introduce time t as a parameter for tracking velocity and change,
while in some articles it is treated as a fifth dimension.
The approach differs from "Wick rotation"
or complex Euclidean relativity. Wick rotation replaces time t by it, which
also yields a positive definite metric but it maintains proper time as the invariant value whereas in Euclidean relativity
becomes a coordinate.
The Euclidean geometry is consistent with Minkowski based relativity. The hyperbolic
Minkowski geometry turns into a rotation in 4D circular geometry where length contraction and time
dilation result from the geometric projection of 4D properties to our 3D space.
The justification for the Euclidean approach is twofold: it makes relativity
accessible in an intuitive way and it opens new opportunities to further develop
Below are a number of references to articles on Euclidean relativity published
by various authors. Each author approaches the topic in his own way and
individual interpretations were often developed independently without knowledge
of the other authors. First fundamental work came from the Dutch mathematician
Hans Montanus in the beginning of the 90's.
Prof. Robert d'E Atkinson Probably the first exploration of Euclidean relativity in history.
General Relativity in Euclidean Terms (Proceedings of the Royal
Society of London. Series A, Mathematical and Physical Sciences, Volume 272, Issue 1348, pp. 60-78, 02-1963(!)).
Does not yet use proper time as fourth spatial dimension because it only deals with general relativity with stationary
Dr. R. G. Newburgh, Dr. T. E. Phipps US Air Force research paper.
A Space-Proper Time Formulation of Relativistic Geometry (Air Force Cambridge Research Laboratories, Office of Aerospace Research, U.S. Air Force, 1969)
Seems like the first proposal to use proper time as fourth spatial dimension.
See also this document for a complete listing and biography of Dr. Phipps.
Drs. Hans Montanus Introduces the difference between
Relative and Absolute Euclidean space-times (REST versus AEST), while he
favors the latter.
Special relativity in an absolute Euclidean Space-Time
(Physics Essays, vol 4, nr 3, 1991)
The Fizeau experiment in an absolute Euclidean Space-time
(Physics Essays, vol 5, nr 4, 1992)
A new concept of time
(Physics Essays, vol 6 nr 4, 1993)
General relativity in an absolute Euclidean space-time
(Physics Essays, vol 8, nr 4, 1995)
Electrodynamics in an absolute Euclidean space-time
(Physics Essays, vol 10, nr 1, 1997)
Arguments against the general theory of relativity and for a flat alternative
(Physics Essays, vol 10 nr 4, 1997)
Compton scattering, pair annihilation, and Pion decay in an absolute Euclidean space-time
(Physics Essays, vol 11, nr 2, 1998)
A Geometrical Explanation for the Deflection of Light
(Physics Essays, vol 11, nr 3, 1998)
Hyperbolic Orbits in an Absolute Euclidean Space-time
(Physics Essays, vol 11 nr 4, 1998)
Proper Time Physics
(PDF) (Hadronic J.22:625-673,1999)
Galactic Rotation and Dark Matter in an Absolute Euclidean Space-time
(Physics Essays, vol 12 nr 2, 1999)
Proper-Time Formulation of Relativistic Dynamics
(Found. Phys. 31, Issue 9, Sep 2001, Pages 1357 - 1400)
Flat Space Gravitation
(Found. Phys. 35, Issue 9, Sep 2005, Pages 1543 - 1562)
Talk at the IARD conference 2004.
Jose Almeida An Euclidean extrapolation to general relativity, explaining geodesic motion of objects as a result of
a 4D refractive index, hence the alternative name '4D Optics'. Almeida considers 4D space-time as a Euclidean null-subspace of a 5D space-time
with metric (-++++). The approach allows a treatment of mass particles in 4D
equivalent to photons in 3D, which is supplemented by considering particle worldlines as normals to wavefronts.
An alternative to Minkowski space-time
4-Dimensional optics, an alternative to relativity
A theory of mass and gravity in 4-dimensional optics
K-calculus in 4-dimensional optics
Prospects for unification under 4-dimensional optics
Unification of classic and quantum mechanics
Maxwell's equations in 4-dimensional Euclidean space
Euclidean formulation of general relativity
The null subspace of G(4,1) as source of the main physical theories
Talk at the Moscow conference Number Time Relativity 2004
Talk at the PIRT IX conference Londen 2004.
Choice of the best geometry to explain physics
Monogenic functions in 5-dimensional spacetime used as first principle: gravitational dynamics, electromagnetism and quantum mechanics
How much in the Universe can be explained by geometry?
Prof. Alexander Gersten Uses the term 'Mixed Space' to refer to the space where time t and proper time have changed place. Probably the first one to recognize the value of Montanus' work.
Talk at the IARD conference 2002.
Euclidean Special Relativity
(PDF) (Found. Phys. 33, 2003, Pages 1237-1251)
Dr. Richard Gauthier Also proposes a modification in
the Minkoswki spacetime metric where time t and proper time
change place. The idea originated from a study of the relativistic
energy-momentum components of a theoretical model for the electron being
composed of a circulating spin-1/2 charged photon.
Electrons are spin 1/2 charged photons generating the de Broglie wavelength
(Proceedings of SPIE Vol. 9570 95700D-1, 2015)
Derivation of the Inertial Mass m = E o / c 2 of an Electron Composed of a Circling Spin-1/2 Charged Photon
Carl Brannen MSc. Emphasis on the geometry and mathematics (geometric or Clifford algebra) that could be used as a basis for Euclidean relativity.
The Proper Time Geometry (pdf, ver 1.0 10/19/2004)
Phase Velocity of de Broglie Waves (pdf, ver 1.0 11/20/2004)
The Geometry of Fermions (pdf, ver 1.01, 10/21/2004)
The Geometric Speed of Light (pdf, ver 1.0 11/07/2004)
Nonlinear Waves on the Geometric Algebra (pdf, ver 1.1 12/02/2004)
Homepage of Carl with various other papers on particle physics.
Dr. Giorgio Fontana Summarizes the results of Montanus, Gersten and Almeida in his first article and extends this with some more speculative thoughts
The Four Space-times Model of Reality
Hyperspace for Space Travel,
Video of presentation at the STAIF 2007 by Dr. Eric Davis
(American Institute of Physics, C.P. 880, pp. 1117-1124)
Gravitational Waves in Euclidean Space
(Excerpt from AIP Conference Proceedings 969, 1055 (2008))
On the foundations of Gravitation Inertia and Gravitational Waves
(Scribd) Extending Maxwell's equations to Euclidean relativity in 5D
Towards an Unified Engineering Model for Long (and short?) Range Forces and Wave Propagation
Homepage of Giorgio Fontana.
Dr. Anthony Crabbe As an alternative to the traditional Minkowski hyperbolic geometry the author uses 'Circular Function Geometry' (CFG), which is natural for many Euclidean
interpretations of special relativity.
Alternative conventions and geometry for Special Relativity
(Annales de la Fondation Louis de Broglie Vol 29 no 4, 2004)
The Limitations of the Minkowski Model of Space-time
talk at the 13th Triennial Conference of the International Society for the Study of Time (Monterery, CA July 28-Aug 3 2007)
Albert Zur Ph.D. A comprehensive study of four-vectors based
on the characteristic properties of Euclidean relativity in momentum-space.
A Theory of Special Relativity Based on Four-Displacement of Particles Instead of Minkowski Four-Position
Rob F.J. Van Linden BSc.
Minkowski versus Euclidean 4-vectors
(web, feb 2006) Associating 4-vectors with geometric properties in Euclidean space-time.
Euclidean Special relativity
(web, sep 2017) Essentials of the approach in Euclidean relativity.
Relativity Simplified Simplified and popularized description of the essentials of Euclidean relativity.
The Universe as a Multi-Dimensional Fractal
Speculative description of a fractal-like universe,
based on the geometry of Euclidean relativity. It suggests a hierarchical ordering of the four forces of Nature together with
their fermions and bosons through their number of dimensions and provides answers to the expansion of the universe and its missing mass.
Dr. Phillips V. Bradford Characteristic elements of Euclidean relativity, using proper time and universal velocity c for all objects in space-time.
Alternative ways of looking at physics, with amongst others
A space-time, geometric interpretation of the beta factor in Special Relativity.
Richard D. Stafford Ph.D., Resolution of the Relativity/Quantum Mechanics Conflict
(on Web Archive) Uses Euclidean space-time with as fourth dimension to solve a common problem with the perception of reality.
Note on articles by Dr. Frans-Guenter Winkler (website,
arXiv): although the same terms Euclidean special and general relativity are used, the
geometry of the model is different. It maintains t as fourth dimension and as invariant, yet uses a (++++)
metric. The approach falls outside the scope of this page.
Hans Montanus' visualization of the relation between Minkowski and Euclidean diagrams (From: Proper Time Physics, Hadronic Journal 22, 625-673, 1999)
Lewis Carroll Epstein Relativity Visualized (Insight Press 1981) A popular explanation of special relativity using concepts of Euclidean relativity.
Brian Greene The Fabric of the Cosmos: Space, Time, and the Texture of Reality (Knopf New York 2004) Typical elements of Euclidean Relativity are used at various places in the book to explain relativistic
Thomas W. Sills What Einstein did not see (Dearborn Resources 2009) Introduces proper time as fourth dimension and uses circular diagrams for
velocities in space and time.
David Eckstein Epstein Explains Einstein (free ebook 2009) An explanation of Epstein's book
5D Space-Time-Matter consortium, coordinated by Prof. Paul Wesson.
Not so much identifiable as Euclidean relativity but proposals very similar to
the ideas in it regarding the application of a fifth dimension, based on the
Campbell-Magaard embedding theorem.
A quote from an article of Paul Wesson,
In Defense of Campbell's Theorem as a Frame for New Physics
(arXiv.org gr-qc/0507107, July 25th 2005)
reflects one of the key elements in van Linden's article "The Universe as a Multi-Dimensional Fractal" :
"The implication of this for particles is clear: they should travel on null 5D geodesics. This idea has recently been taken up in the literature, and has a
considerable future. It means that what we perceive as massive particles in 4D are akin to photons in 5D."
Updated August 2018 by Rob van Linden